2.10 carat emerald cut lab grown diamond, I color, VVS2 clarity
Lab Grown Diamonds

IGI vs GIA Certificate for Lab Grown Diamonds: What's the Difference?

by Aumsri Pradhan on Sep 28, 2026

Quick answer: For most lab grown diamonds sold in the US today, an IGI report is the more useful certificate because it lists the full grades: cut, color, clarity, carat and measurements. Since October 1, 2025, GIA no longer gives lab grown diamonds letter grades for color and clarity. Instead, it labels them "Premium" or "Standard," which confirms quality but makes side-by-side comparison harder.

Both labs are respected and independent. The difference is in how much detail each report gives you, so it helps to know what to look for before you buy.

What Does an IGI Lab Grown Diamond Report Show?

The International Gemological Institute (IGI) grades the large majority of lab grown diamonds on the US market. A typical IGI report for a lab grown diamond includes:

  • Carat weight and measurements in millimeters.
  • Color grade on the D to Z scale.
  • Clarity grade, from Flawless down through VVS, VS and SI.
  • Cut, polish and symmetry grades.
  • Growth method (CVD or HPHT) and whether the stone was treated after growth.
  • A report number, usually laser-inscribed on the diamond's girdle.

What Changed With GIA Lab Grown Reports?

GIA used to grade lab grown diamonds much like natural ones. In 2025 it changed its approach. For lab grown diamonds submitted from October 1, 2025, GIA no longer issues individual D-to-Z color or clarity grades. Each stone is described as either Premium or Standard, based on an overall assessment of color, clarity and finish. A stone that does not meet GIA's minimum bar receives no designation.

GIA reports issued before that date are still valid and keep their original letter grades. GIA also grades only a small share of lab grown diamonds, so you will see IGI reports far more often when shopping.

IGI vs GIA: Side-by-Side Comparison

IGI report GIA report (from Oct 2025)
Color grade Letter grade, D to Z Rolled into Premium or Standard
Clarity grade Specific grade, e.g. VS1 Rolled into Premium or Standard
Cut, polish, symmetry Listed Part of the overall assessment
Confirms lab grown Yes Yes
How common on US listings Very common Less common
Best for Comparing exact grades between stones A simple quality tier from GIA

Which Certificate Should You Choose?

Choose the report that lets you compare what you are paying for. If you are weighing two 1.5 carat ovals, an IGI report shows you exactly how their color and clarity differ, so you can decide whether an upgrade is worth the price. A GIA Premium or Standard label tells you the stone passed GIA's quality bar, but two Standard stones can still look slightly different.

Whichever lab you see, run these three checks before you buy:

  • Match the number. The report number on the listing should match the certificate and the girdle inscription.
  • Match the details. Carat weight, shape and measurements on the report should match the product page.
  • Verify online. Both IGI and GIA let you look up a report number on their websites.

2.10 carat emerald cut lab grown diamond, I color, VVS2 clarityShown: 2.10 Ct Emerald Cut Lab Grown Diamond, I Color, VVS2, IGI Certified

How to Read a Lab Grown Diamond Report, Line by Line

A grading report looks technical, but it follows the same order almost every time. Once you know what each line means, you can compare two stones in a couple of minutes and spot a listing that does not add up.

Report number and date

The report number is the stone's ID. It is what you type into the lab's online lookup, and on most lab grown diamonds it is also laser-inscribed on the girdle. The date matters for GIA, because it tells you whether the report was issued before or after the October 2025 change to Premium and Standard tiers.

Shape and cutting style

This line names the outline and facet pattern, for example "Round Brilliant" or "Emerald Step Cut." It sounds obvious, but it confirms that the stone you see in photos is the stone on the paper. A cushion described as a "Cushion Modified Brilliant" will sparkle differently from a cushion with a more traditional facet pattern.

Measurements and carat weight

Measurements are given in millimeters as length x width x depth. Carat is weight, not size, so two 1.00 carat stones can face up at different sizes if one is cut deep. Use the millimeter width to judge how big the diamond will look on the hand, and use the length-to-width ratio to judge the shape of fancy cuts like ovals and pears.

Color, clarity and cut grades

On an IGI report these are separate letter or word grades you can compare directly. On a post-2025 GIA lab grown report they are folded into the single Premium or Standard designation. Older GIA reports still show the full grades.

Polish, symmetry and fluorescence

Polish and symmetry describe the finish of the facets and how evenly they line up. Fluorescence describes how the stone reacts to ultraviolet light, graded from None through Faint, Medium, Strong and Very Strong. Most lab grown diamonds show none or faint fluorescence, and in normal lighting it rarely changes how a stone looks.

Growth method and treatment

IGI reports usually state whether the diamond was grown by CVD or HPHT and whether there are signs of post-growth treatment. Many CVD diamonds are given a heat treatment after growth to improve color, which is a standard and permanent process. The report simply discloses it so you know what you are buying.

Comments, proportions and plot

The comments section lists anything that does not fit elsewhere, such as the inscription text or extra facets. Many reports also include a proportions diagram (table, depth, crown and pavilion angles) and a clarity plot that maps where the inclusions sit. A plot is useful because an inclusion near the edge can be hidden by a prong, while one under the table is easier to see.

The Grading Scales Behind the Report

Both labs grade lab grown diamonds against the same diamond scales used for mined diamonds. The labels below are what you will see on an IGI report and on older GIA lab grown reports.

Grade Scale What it means for you
Color D, E, F (colorless), G to J (near colorless), K to M (faint), N to Z (light color) Most engagement ring shoppers land in the D to J range. The difference between neighboring grades is very hard to see once the stone is set.
Clarity FL, IF, VVS1, VVS2, VS1, VS2, SI1, SI2, I1, I2, I3 VS and above are usually eye-clean. SI stones need a closer look at where the inclusions sit.
Cut (round) GIA: Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor. IGI: Ideal, Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor Cut drives sparkle more than any other grade. For a round, aim for the top grade on the lab's scale.
Polish and symmetry Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor Excellent or Very Good is the norm for well-made lab grown stones.

One detail trips people up: IGI's top cut grade for rounds is called Ideal, while GIA's top grade is Excellent. An IGI "Excellent" is therefore one step below its top grade, not the same as a GIA Excellent. For a deeper look at each scale, see our guides to G color lab grown diamonds and VS1 vs VS2 clarity.

What a Certificate Does Not Tell You

A report is a precise description of a loose stone, but it is not the full picture. Keep these gaps in mind when you compare listings:

  • How it looks set. The report grades a loose stone. Metal color, prong style and a halo all change how the finished ring reads.
  • Where the inclusions are visible. Two VS2 stones can look different if one inclusion is dark and central and the other is light and near the edge. Check the plot and the photos.
  • Light performance on fancy shapes. Labs only give an overall cut grade for round diamonds. For ovals, pears, emeralds and other shapes, you judge cut from proportions, photos and video.
  • Value or price. A grading report is not an appraisal. It describes quality but does not put a dollar figure on the stone.

Grading Report vs Appraisal vs Store Card

Shoppers often use these words as if they mean the same thing. They do not, and mixing them up can lead to a poor comparison.

  • Grading report. Issued by an independent lab such as IGI or GIA. It describes the stone's characteristics and identifies it as lab grown.
  • Appraisal. Written by an appraiser, usually for insurance. It estimates a replacement value and describes the whole piece of jewelry, including metal.
  • Store or brand card. A document created by the seller. It can be helpful, but it is not an independent grade.

If you plan to insure a ring, you will usually need an appraisal in addition to the grading report. Our guide on insuring a lab grown diamond ring walks through that side of it.

Lab Grown vs Mined vs Moissanite: How the Paperwork Differs

Lab grown diamonds are real diamonds: carbon, 10 on the Mohs scale and a refractive index of about 2.42. That is why IGI and GIA grade them on diamond scales and why both labs clearly state "laboratory grown" on the report and usually on the girdle inscription.

  • Mined diamonds get natural diamond reports from the same labs, with full color and clarity grades from GIA.
  • Lab grown diamonds get IGI reports with full grades, or GIA reports with Premium or Standard tiers for stones submitted after October 1, 2025.
  • Moissanite is silicon carbide, a different gem. It rates about 9.25 on the Mohs scale, has a higher refractive index of about 2.65 and shows more colorful fire. It is not graded on diamond scales, so any paperwork is usually a seller or maker card rather than an independent diamond report.

A standard thermal diamond tester will read a lab grown diamond as diamond, so a tester cannot tell you whether a stone is lab grown or mined. That takes lab equipment, which is one more reason the report and inscription matter. Compare all three side by side on our moissanite vs lab grown diamond vs diamond page.

Do Small Diamonds Need a Certificate?

Usually not. Accent stones in a pave band or halo are too small to certify individually. Certification matters most for a center stone, typically 0.5 carat and up, where color and clarity have the biggest effect on looks and price.

Shop the styles in this guide

Which Pieces Need IGI or GIA Paperwork?

How much a report matters depends on the jewelry, the size of the stones and how you plan to compare them.

Engagement rings and solitaires

A center stone is where a report earns its keep. In a lab diamond solitaire ring, the single stone carries the whole look, so knowing its exact color, clarity and cut grades helps you balance size against quality.

Stud earrings

For larger stud earrings, the goal is a matched pair. Reports on each stone, or a close match in color and size, keep one ear from looking whiter or bigger than the other.

Tennis chains, bracelets and pave pieces

A lab grown tennis chain or a pave band can hold dozens of small stones. These are graded as a group for consistency, not one by one, so look at the overall color and clarity range described for the piece rather than expecting individual certificates.

Does the Metal Change What the Report Says?

No. The report describes the loose diamond, and it stays the same whatever setting you choose. What changes is how the stone looks on your hand. White metals such as 925 sterling silver or white gold keep colorless and near colorless stones looking crisp. Yellow and rose gold, from 10K to 18K, reflect warm color into the diamond, so a near colorless grade like H or I can look just as good as a higher grade in those settings.

This is a practical way to use the report: decide on the metal first, then pick the color grade that looks right in that metal instead of paying for a grade the setting will mask.

Common Certificate Mistakes to Avoid

  • Comparing an IGI grade to a GIA tier as if they were the same. A GIA Standard stone and an IGI VS2 G stone are described in different ways. Compare like with like whenever you can.
  • Assuming IGI Excellent cut is the top grade. For rounds, IGI's top grade is Ideal.
  • Skipping the online check. A photo of a report is not proof. Look up the number on the lab's website.
  • Ignoring the measurements. A deep stone can carry extra weight without looking bigger. The millimeter width tells you more about face-up size than carat.
  • Buying on paper alone. Grades narrow the field. Photos, video and proportions decide which stone actually looks best.
  • Losing the report. Keep a digital copy with your other important documents. You will want it for insurance, cleaning visits or a future upgrade.

Step-by-Step: Checking a Lab Grown Diamond Certificate Before You Buy

  1. Find the lab name and report number on the listing.
  2. Look up that number on the IGI or GIA website and confirm the shape, carat and measurements match the listing.
  3. Check that the report states the stone is laboratory grown and notes the growth method or any treatment.
  4. Read color, clarity and cut (or the GIA tier) and compare them with the other stones on your shortlist.
  5. Review the proportions and the clarity plot to see where inclusions sit.
  6. Match the girdle inscription to the report number, using a loupe or the seller's photos.
  7. Think about the setting and metal, and make sure the grades you are paying for will actually show.
  8. Save a copy of the report with your purchase records.

Who Each Report Suits Best

An IGI report suits shoppers who like to compare details, who are choosing a center stone of half a carat or more, or who want to trade size against color and clarity with full information.

A GIA Premium or Standard report suits buyers who prefer a simple pass-or-tier answer from GIA and who will choose the final stone mainly by eye from photos or in person.

Either report works as long as the number checks out online, the details match the listing and the stone looks the way you want.

Keep Your Diamond Looking Like Its Report

A lab grown diamond will not turn cloudy, change color or lose its sparkle over time. When a diamond looks dull, the cause is almost always a film of skin oil, lotion or soap on the back of the stone. Soak it in warm water with a little mild dish soap, brush gently behind the stone with a soft toothbrush, rinse and dry with a lint-free cloth. Our jewelry care guide covers metals and settings in more detail.

If a prong ever needs repair or the stone is reset, the laser inscription lets a jeweler confirm the diamond against its report, so you always know it is the same stone you bought.

How Certification Works at Ivevar

We handcraft our jewelry in our own workshop in Surat, India, and offer free worldwide shipping. For certified loose diamonds, we share the grading report before you buy so you can check the grades and verify the number yourself. Browse our certified loose lab grown diamonds or choose a finished lab grown diamond engagement ring.

Shop IGI Certified Lab Grown Diamonds

2.10 carat emerald cut lab grown diamond2.10 Ct Emerald, I Color, VVS2Shop Now2.06 carat marquise cut lab grown diamond2.06 Ct Marquise, F Color, VVS2Shop Now3.17 carat heart cut lab grown diamond3.17 Ct Heart, I Color, VS1Shop Now2.96 carat princess cut lab grown diamond2.96 Ct Princess, I Color, VS1Shop Now3.10 carat princess cut lab grown diamond3.10 Ct Princess, I Color, VS1Shop Now0.25 carat princess cut lab grown diamond0.25 Ct Princess, F Color, VVS2Shop Now

Swipe to see more → | View all loose lab grown diamonds

Frequently Asked Questions

Is IGI as good as GIA for lab grown diamonds?

For lab grown diamonds, IGI is the most widely used lab and gives the most detailed grades. GIA is highly respected but now uses broad Premium and Standard labels for lab grown stones.

Is my older GIA lab grown report still valid?

Yes. Reports issued before October 1, 2025 keep their original color and clarity grades.

What does GIA Premium mean?

Premium is GIA's top quality tier for lab grown diamonds, based on its overall read of color, clarity and finish. Standard is the tier below it.

Should I buy a lab grown diamond without a certificate?

For a center stone, we recommend a report from an independent lab. It protects you by confirming the grades and that the stone is lab grown.

Does a certificate prove a diamond is lab grown?

Yes. Both IGI and GIA identify the stone as laboratory grown on the report, and the girdle inscription usually says so too. Telling lab grown from mined by eye or with a basic tester is not possible, so the report is your proof.

Will a diamond tester say my lab grown diamond is real?

Yes. A standard thermal tester reads a lab grown diamond as diamond because it is one. Moissanite can fool older thermal testers, which is why many jewelers also use a tester that checks electrical conductivity.

Is IGI Ideal cut the same as GIA Excellent cut?

Both are the top cut grade on each lab's scale for round diamonds. The names differ, so compare stones from the same lab whenever possible.

Is a grading report the same as an appraisal?

No. A grading report describes the diamond's quality. An appraisal estimates a value for the finished piece, usually for insurance.

The Bottom Line

An IGI report gives you the detail you need to compare lab grown diamonds grade by grade. A GIA report gives a simpler quality tier. Either way, match the report number and the details to the listing, and ask questions before you buy.

Related Guides

Aumsri Pradhan, Ivevar Luxury

Author Bio

Aumsri Pradhan

Founder, Ivevar Luxury


Aumsri Pradhan is the founder of Ivevar Luxury, a Surat-based fine jewelry brand that designs and handcrafts lab grown diamond and moissanite jewelry in its own workshop. She leads the brand's design and customer experience, from engagement rings and bridal sets to custom pieces made to each client's story. Through the Ivevar blog, she shares practical guidance on lab grown diamonds, moissanite, diamond grading and ring design to help buyers choose with confidence.

View author profile ›